16 Halloween Candies That Will Spook You

Trick or treat? How about both?! We all know Hershey bars, Kit-Kats, and Skittles, but there are some less popular candies on the shelves right now that are sure to spook you and your trick or treaters. From “Bloody Bites” to rat shaped gummies, let’s take a look at the Halloween candies that will shake up your candy bowls!

Get ready to add a spine-chilling twist to your Halloween candy stash. 

We’ve created a list of 16 different candies that are sure to give you goosebumps. Whether you prefer ghoulish gummies or chilling chocolates, there’s something on this list for everyone’s candy taste. 

So whether you’re daring your taste buds or aiming to give you guests a good fright, these candies are your ticket to a hauntingly sweet Halloween experience!

1. Black Licorice Jelly Beans

Black licorice jelly beans – you’ll either love them or you’ll hate them! They have a bold, polarizing flavor that just might send shivers down your spine. 

Jelly Belly is certainly known for their funky flavors, always making new flavors to spark conversation. So it only makes sense that one of their classic flavors could become a Halloween staple. 

Whether you’re a die-hard fan or they’re your candy kryptonite, one thing’s for sure, these jelly beans will be a spook-tacular addition to your trick-or-treat stash.

2. Gummy Eyeballs

Keep an eye out for terrifying treats! Gummy eyeballs are the Halloween candies that will make you do a double-take. 

These eerily realistic confections are not for the faint of heart. Whether you’re daring enough to take a bite or prefer to keep them as eerie decorations, these eyeballs will add a ghastly touch to your Halloween spread. You’ll see candy in a whole new, slightly creepy, light!

3. Chocolate-Covered Insects

Chocolate-covered insects are here to add a creepy crunch to your candy selection! 

These critter-filled confections are not for the faint of heart. Originally made popular in Thailand, the most popular insects to cover with chocolate are grasshoppers and silkworms. 

With every bite, you’ll be venturing into uncharted territory. If you like sweet and savory, this treat might be your treat! Dare to indulge in this entomological extravaganza!

4. Bloody Bites (Gummy Teeth)

Sink your teeth into the spooky side of sweets with Bloody Bites! These gummy teeth look like they’ve taken a bite out of something sinister. 

A perfect blend of creepy and chewy, they’re sure to add a dash of fright to your trick or treaters nights. Just be careful not to scare off your dentist!

5. Worms and Dirt

A nice combination of gummy and savory chocolate, worms and dirt is a concoction of gummy worms in Oreo crumbs. These gummy worms slithering through Oreo crumbs are a ghoulish delight for the senses.

This treat is a classic, even Disney World has their own version of it now. It’s a treat that plays tricks on both your eyes and taste buds, giving you a sweet, creepy-crawly experience. Don’t be surprised if your guests are digging in for seconds!

6. Sour Octopus Gummies

Trolli is infamous for their wild gummy flavors. They didn’t disappoint when diving into the deep sea of flavor while making these sour octopus gummies. 

These tentacled treats bring a tangy twist to the Halloween candy scene. Their lifelike appearance and sour punch make them an underwater adventure for your taste buds. 

Beware, one taste and you might find yourself hooked!

7. Chocolate-Covered Brains

Brains, anyone? Morkes chocolate now sells an anatomically correct chocolate covered brain. Dive headfirst into the deliciously creepy world of chocolate covered brains on Halloween if you’re expecting a lot of trick or treaters dressed up as doctors or nurses (or zombies!)

These anatomically correct confections are a must have for any Halloween spread. With a delectable outer shell and a gooey center, they’re a cerebral treat that’s as scary as they are scrumptious. 

Get ready to outsmart your tastebuds!

8. Rat-Shaped Gummies

From Jelly Belly to Haribo, rat shaped gummies are not hard to find in the candy market. You can even buy a gummy pet rat now! These gummies are not your average candy critters. With their (slightly) realistic appearance, they’re sure to scurry their way into your Halloween festivities. 

But, don’t worry, these sweet rodents are far more charming than their real life counterparts. Just keep them away from your cheese board!

9. Glow-in-the-Dark Lollipops

We’ve all seen some pretty wild lollipops, but these ones will light up your Halloween night! These luminous treats bring an eerie glow to all your Halloween celebrations. They’re the perfect way to add an otherworldly touch to your candy bowl!

10. Toothpaste Flavored Gum

Trick, treat, or brush your teeth? This cheeky confection looks like regular gum but actually delivers a surprise zing of minty freshness!

While it’s a prank candy, the scariest part of this treat is the reminder it gives you about dental health amidst Halloween snacking! Holidays are the biggest culprits of oral health problems. Teeth cleanings, cavities, and dental appointments, oh my! 

11. Ghost Pepper Chocolate 

We all like a little spice with our sweets sometimes. So, turn up the heat this Halloween with ghost pepper chocolate! 

The spicy kick from this chocolate will haunt your taste buds and add a hair-raising element to your candy stash. This treat is as daring as it is delicious!

12. Chili-Flavored Lollipops

Originally a Mexican treat, these lollipops will spice up your Halloween! These fiery pops pack a punch and will warm you up on a chilly October night. 

With each lick, you’ll be daring your taste buds to brave the heat. It’s a candy that’s bound to leave a sizzle!

13. Coffin-shaped Chocolate Bars 

Looking to embrace the afterlife this Halloween? Do it with these Coffin-shaped chocolate bars! It seems that people will make chocolate shaped as nearly anything, and these spooky coffins are no different!

These treats are hauntingly delicious and are bound to add a touch of gothic elegance to your Halloween spread. They’re a sweet reminder that life is short, so savor every bite!

14. Bloody Bandages (Fruit Roll-ups)

Need a quick patch-up this Halloween? Look no further, fan favorite fruit roll-ups can do the trick! 

These ghastly goods, made with fruit roll ups and strawberry syrup, are a gory twist on the classic treat. With their eerily realistic appearance, they will surely give your guests a spooky surprise!

15. Creepy Crawly Spider Lollipops 

Add an arachnid twist to your Halloween treats with Creepy Crawly Spider Lollipops!

Add pipe cleaner legs to the stem of any lollipop, and you’ll have a creepy creature! These eight-legged lollies will bring a touch of spookiness to your candy stash. You’ll get up close and personal with these deliciously eerie critters with every lick! 

To add some more Halloween flair, make these with zodiac lollipops to play with fate while spooking your trick or treaters!

16. Witches’ Brew Gumballs

Have your guests step into the witches’ lair with a bewitching concoction: Witches’ Brew Gumballs! These gumballs come in a purple so dark they almost look black in order to have a haunting effect. Halloween is no stranger to witches’ brew treats, even Starbucks plays on the gimmick!

These Dubble Bubble magical orbs are infused with flavors that dance on your taste buds like a cauldron bubbling with charm. With every chew, you’ll be under the spell of a sweet, enigmatic brew.

Taking off the costume…

From spooky jelly beans to gummies that mimic eerie creatures, this lineup of Halloween candy proves that the upcoming spooky season isn’t just about costumes and decorations – it’s about the daring your taste buds and delighting in the devilishly creepy. 

Whether you’re a fan of the spine tingling or just out for a laugh, these treats will offer a bewitching twist to your candy bowl. 

Let’s go ahead, embrace the scare, and let your taste buds embark on a hair-raising adventure. 

Happy haunting, and may your Halloween be as sweet as it is spooky!