Most of us grew up eating peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, well now there’s a growing list of flavors that we definitely would not have found in grandma’s pantry. Let’s take a look below.
1. Gin & Tonic
Photo by Firebox
So, honestly I’m dying to try this! Being my go-to drink at a bar, this spread is the most appealing to me. Made with gin, sugar, lemon, water, and quinine extract. The alcohol is cooked off in the process so there is no worry of a boozy breakfast toast. Only available from Firebox in the UK, I’ll keep dreaming about it.
Recommendation: Because of the strong flavor profiles we suggest a simple buttered toast with a thin layer of this marmalade.
2. Cookie Dough Marshmallow Fluff
Photo by Toasted Mallow
Cookie dough lovers rejoice! Toasted Mallow has created your new favorite sandwich spreads. Combining gourmet marshmallow fluff with edible cookie dough, this spread is for those with a strong sweet tooth. They offer flavors like chocolate chip, red velvet, and birthday cake.
Recommendation: Make a peanut butter sandwich with one of these fluffs to satisfy any craving. Toast your bread too!
3. Brownie Batter Hummus
Photo by Delighted by Hummus
If you love cookie dough, then you probably love cake batter, which means you probably love brownie batter. You’re in luck! Delighted by Hummus is giving you all the nutritional value of hummus but adding the delicious taste of brownie batter.
Recommendation: Try this with some pretzel chips for a somewhat healthy snack! 😉
4. Dill Pickle Dip
Photo by HeluvaGood!
Technically a dip, this HeluvaGood! product can still be used as a spread on any sandwich. It’s really up to you. Made with a creamy base of garlic, dill, and mustard this dip/spread also has pieces of dehydrated cucumbers in it. Salty and sour, this is perfect for anyone who loves pickles.
Recommendation: Try this with a turkey sandwich or your favorite potato chip!
5. Cookie Butter
Photo by Trader Joe's
Already a cult classic, Trader Joe’s Speculoos Cookie Butter is something you have to try! Made with gingersnap flavors and pieces, this spread is a cookie lover’s dream. Coming in smooth and crunchy variations, this spread is good by the spoonful or in a sandwich.
Recommendation: Try this on a sandwich with bananas and marshmallow fluff.
6. Cookies and Cream Hazelnut Spread
Photo by Target
This spread is really for those of you who consider sugar to be one of the essential food groups. An overload of sweetness with the chocolate cookie and cream spread mixed with classic hazelnut makes this spread one to try!
Recommendation: Try swirling this in your vanilla ice cream for the sweetest of treats.
7. Caramel Almond Spread
Photo by MaraNatha
This classic combination of flavors is perfect to put a twist on the old school peanut butter and jelly. This all-natural spread combines the subtle sweetness of caramel and the rich flavors of almonds and it’s perfect for eating every day.
Recommendation: Try this on a sandwich with some orange marmalade for a delicious afternoon snack
8. Tabasco Spicy Pepper Jelly
Photo by Tabasco
This Jelly is not for the faint of heart. With a whole lotta heat and a tad bit of sweet, this is reserved for the adventurous eater!
Recommendation: Try this on a ritz cracker with plain cream cheese.
