DoorDash Admits It ‘Screwed Up’ After Agreeing to Pay $131.5 Million to Underpaid Workers


DoorDash has reached a $131.5 million settlement with New York City’s Department of Consumer and Worker Protection over wages that the food delivery company failed to pay in full or on time. The agreement follows a city investigation and covers roughly 264,000 workers, whom DoorDash calls Dashers. In a Sept. 22 statement on its website, the San Francisco-based company said, “Simply put, we screwed up.”
Pay for Time Between Deliveries

The biggest share of the settlement, more than $83 million, resolves a dispute with the city over how to calculate pay for the time Dashers spend logged into the app between deliveries. Compensation for that downtime is a major point of contention across the industry, the BBC reported. New York’s rules cover every minute a driver is logged in, though apps have historically paid only while an order was in progress.
DoorDash’s Apology to Dashers

“We pride ourselves on operational excellence at DoorDash, and this was not excellent, nor was it acceptable,” the company wrote in that same statement on the settlement. DoorDash said the mistakes were not intentional, though that did not make them okay. It also said Dashers “should be paid in full, on time, every time,” and apologized to the Dashers it let down.
What DoorDash Says Went Wrong

DoorDash pointed to “complex” changes to New York’s minimum pay rules for delivery workers, introduced in 2023, as one reason for the errors. The company also cited technical bugs and complicated situations, including deliveries that spanned city lines, orders with multiple stops, and trips that were partly completed or canceled. In other cases, the company said, errors stemmed from incomplete or inaccurate banking information from Dashers.
Missed and Late Payments

The settlement also includes $12.3 million for payments that were missed or late, according to DoorDash. The BBC reported that systemic errors meant about $6.6 million in wages never reached workers, while $5.7 million more showed up days or weeks late. DoorDash said the issues affected under 1% of its overall transactions in the city. It also said local workers earn roughly $30 per active hour on average.
Mayor Mamdani Responds

Mayor Zohran Mamdani said the agreement is the largest labor enforcement action the city has taken. Speaking at a press conference, he said DoorDash used “greedy algorithms” and did not comply with a 2023 city law aimed at improving pay for delivery workers. “For years, DoorDash failed to count every hour worked by delivery workers,” Mamdani said. “This was not a rounding error or an accidental mistake.”
The Fixes and the Fine

DoorDash said it has fixed the software problems behind the errors and now checks banking details more carefully, so mistakes are caught before a payment goes missing. The company also said it has strengthened its compliance program to reduce the chance of a repeat. Under the settlement, DoorDash will give the city detailed pay data every month for three years and will pay a $16.7 million civil fine, Reuters reported.
What Workers Will Receive

Nearly $115 million of the settlement will go to about 264,000 workers in relief payments, with a median payout of about $48, according to Reuters. “Dashers will be paid a minimum of $10, even if they were underpaid by less than that,” the company wrote. DoorDash said it will reach out to all affected workers about the settlement “in the coming weeks.”
Earlier Tip Accusations and the Other Apps

The city’s Department of Consumer and Worker Protection had already accused DoorDash and rival Uber Eats of using “design tricks” to keep more than $550 million in tips out of workers’ hands. That was nearly eight months before the settlement. City officials would not say whether Uber Eats and Grubhub are following the 2023 law. Uber declined to comment when contacted by Reuters, and Grubhub did not respond right away.
A Longer Fight Between Apps and the City

Reuters reported that DoorDash, Uber Eats and Grubhub have been in multiple legal disputes with the city. Those include fights over the city’s tipping laws and over whether the companies must hand customer data to restaurants. DoorDash shares rose 0.2% in afternoon trading. Mayor Zohran Mamdani described the DoorDash settlement as “part of a larger commitment to hold delivery companies accountable.”