What Are the Best Girl Scout Cookie Flavors of 2024? Every Cookie Ranked

Suffolk, Virginia, USA - March 10, 2013: A square format studio shot of several boxes of different flavored Girl Scout Cookies, with focus on the variety called, "Thin Mints". Print texture can be seen on the cardboard of the box.

Get ready to dunk, crunch, and savor as we rank the best Girl Scout cookie flavors of 2024! Find out where your favorites land on our list, ranked from worst to best.

Toffee-tastic (Gluten Free)

Studio shot of handmade white chocolate and honeycomb biscuit cut out against a white background.

Toffee-tastic starts our journey into the world of the best Girl Scout cookies with a unique twist for the gluten-free crowd. If you’re gluten-free, try them out!

While Toffee-tastic has its dedicated fans, it’s worth noting that it might not be everyone’s cup of tea (or cookie, in this case).

Some critics find Toffee-tastics a tad too gritty, which is a common critique for gluten-free baked goods. Others feel they’re a bit on the sweeter side.

Caramel Chocolate Chip (Gluten Free)

Close up Pile of Delicious Chocolate Chip Cookies

Caramel Chocolate Chip cookies are a newer addition to the Girl Scout cookie lineup, being introduced in 2019. But they’ve quickly garnered a fan base.

These cookies blend rich chocolate chips with swirls of caramel in a chewy cookie. They offer a delightful texture and a perfect balance of sweet and buttery.

They’re also gluten-free, making them accessible to those with dietary restrictions. However, some critics point out that the texture can be inconsistent, crumbly, or dry.

Lemon-Ups

Lemon-Up Girl Scout Cookies with package and dessert pudding

Lemon-Ups have quickly zested their way into the hearts of those looking for a tangy twist. Each cookie comes embossed with an inspirational message.

They rank lower in the cookie hierarchy for some cookie connoisseurs due to their tartness. However, Lemon-Ups offer a refreshing break from the sweeter options.

Their crisp, lemony flavor paired with uplifting messages like “I am a leader” and “I am strong” adds a special touch that many cookie enthusiasts appreciate.

Adventurefuls

Girl Scout Adventureful cookies, Reddit

Adventurefuls, a caramel-flavored marvel with a sprinkle of sea salt, are quickly becoming one of the best Girl Scout cookies. They’re like an adventure for your taste buds.

Not just a treat for the taste buds, Adventurefuls add a twist to the classic caramel and sea salt combo, proving why they’re considered among the best Girl Scout cookies.

Despite the allure, some find Adventurefuls a bit overwhelming. The mix of intense flavors and textures isn’t for everyone, with a few people finding them too rich.

Toast-Yay!

Toast-yay Girl Scout cookies, Instagram

Trefoils

Trefoil Girl Scout Cookies branded for a fundraising race next to a lake or body of water, Instagram

Trefoils are the understated classic of the Girl Scout cookie family. They’re a timeless favorite that brings simplicity and elegance to the table or lunchbox.

These shortbread cookies are beloved by many for their delicate, buttery flavor and crisp, light texture. They embody the traditional cookie experience, with a gentle sweetness.

Beyond their delicious taste, Trefoils have a unique place in Girl Scout history, symbolizing the organization’s trefoil-shaped emblem and representing the three parts of the Girl Scout Promise.

Lemonades

Lemonade Girl Scout Cookies on a white plate with a cup of tea, Facebook

Lemonades, with their refreshing citrus kick paired with a sweet, frosted bottom, capture the essence of summer in every bite. They’re a favorite for many.

Fans appreciate the crisp, buttery texture of the shortbread combined with the bright, zesty lemon icing which provides a burst of freshness with every bite.

On the downside, some critics argue that the lemon flavor can sometimes feel a bit artificial or overpowering, which might not appeal to everyone.

Do-Si-Dos (Peanut Butter Sandwich)

A woman's hand holding a box of Do-Si-Do Girl Scout Cookies, Instagram

When talking about the best Girl Scout cookie flavors in 2024, Do-si-dos often fly under the radar. They bring a nutty crunch that’s truly hard to resist.

The filling is sandwiched between two oatmeal cookies that complement the creamy peanut butter perfectly. They might not grab the spotlight like some of their counterparts.

But Do-si-dos offer a subtler pleasure that’s both comforting and familiar. They’re the kind of treat that reminds you of the simple joys of snacking.

Girl Scout S’mores

Package of Girl Scout S'Mores cookies, Facebook

Girl Scout S’mores are the newer kids on the block when it comes to the best Girl Scout cookies, bringing a touch of campfire nostalgia to the lineup.

They are quickly finding their fans, thanks to their delightful crunch and sweet, gooey center. They represent the adventurous spirit of Girl Scouts themselves.

Their place further down this list doesn’t mean they’re any less worthy of a taste test. Like a true underdog, they’re slowly but surely winning hearts.

Peanut Butter Patties (Tagalongs)

Sweet dessert . Chocolate covered marshmallow. Isolated on white background

Tagalongs, or Peanut Butter Patties as some know them, are a match made in cookie heaven, and undeniably among the best Girl Scout cookies out there.

Their perfect blend of creamy peanut butter and smooth chocolate has a way of making taste buds dance in delight. It’s no wonder they’ve captured our hearts!

The crisp cookie base followed by a layer of thick peanut butter, all encased in a chocolate shell, delivers a cookie experience that’s hard to find elsewhere.

Caramel deLites (Samoas)

Samoa cookie in snow, Instagram

Who can resist the allure of Samoas, arguably among the best Girl Scout Cookies out there? Each bite whisks you away to a tropical paradise.

It’s not just the taste that makes Samoas stand out; it’s the texture, too. The chewy caramel, crunchy coconut, and smooth chocolate combine in an irresistible way.

However, Samoas can be divisive. Some find the coconut flavor too dominant or the cookie overall too sweet, which can be overwhelming for those with a milder sweet tooth.

Thin Mints

Thin Mint Girl Scout Cookies, Facebook

When talking about the best Girl Scout cookie flavors in 2024, Thin Mints effortlessly steal the spotlight. These minty, chocolate-coated biscuits have a way of disappearing quickly.

What sets Thin Mints apart in the world of the best Girl Scout cookies? Perhaps it’s their unique blend of rich chocolate and invigorating mint or their versatility.

Whatever the reason, they’re a minty marvel in the cookie kingdom. Thin Mints have also played a pivotal role in teaching countless young scouts about entrepreneurship and sales.

Conclusion

There you have it, a deliciously detailed rundown of the best Girl Scout cookie flavors in 2024, ranked from the not-so-favorite to the ultimate crowd-pleasers. Whether you’re a Thin Mints enthusiast or a Samoa devotee, your cookie choice can reveal a lot about your personality.

Perhaps you’re all about the classics, or maybe you’re a fan of the underdogs. No matter where your favorites landed on our list, we can all agree that Girl Scout cookies bring a little joy into our lives. So, the next time you’re enjoying your favorite box (or two), remember, it’s all in good taste!

Questions and Answers:

Question: What are the best-selling Girl Scout cookies?

Answer: Thin Mints lead the pack, followed closely by Samoas/Caramel deLites.

Question: What’s the newest flavor?

Answer: This changes almost every year as new flavors are introduced to keep things exciting!

Question: Are there vegan or gluten-free options?

Answer: Yes, there are vegan and gluten-free Girl Scout Cookie options. Look for the Toffee-tastic (gluten-free) and Thin Mints (vegan), among others.

Question: How much do Girl Scout cookies cost?

Answer: Prices vary regionally but generally range from $4 to $6 per box.

Question: Where does the cookie money go?

Answer: Funds from cookie sales support local Girl Scout councils and troops in their activities and community projects.

Question: Can you buy Girl Scout Cookies online?

Answer: Yes, Girl Scouts now offer online sales options, making it easier to get your cookie fix.

Did you like it?

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 4.5 / 5. Vote count: 351

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Enjoy Your $19.99 FREE Copy of Our Digital Cookbook!

Enjoy our FREE Digital
Cookbook as Our Way of
Saying Thank You!

I agree to the storing and processing of my personal data by So Yummy as described by the Privacy Policy.

Get your So Yummy Cookbook digital copy - for Free!

Enjoy surprising, smart and absolutely gorgeous home cooking recipes & tips

Thanks for subscribing!

Your Cookbook Awaits in Your Inbox